A Penguin Die-Off First Blamed on Bird Flu Was Mostly Caused by Something Else
When an international research expedition reached Antarctica’s Danger Islands in March 2024, the team found thousands of Adélie penguins lying dead across two islands, along with the carcasses of several other seabird species. The timing pointed to an obvious suspect. H5N1, the highly pathogenic bird flu that has killed wild birds and marine mammals across much of the globe, had only recently reached the Antarctic Peninsula.
But bird flu turned out to be a minor player. In a study published Oct. 14 in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, researchers report that most of the deaths they investigated were caused by avian cholera, a bacterial disease that has nothing to do with influenza.
The bacterium behind it, Pasteurella multocida, was found in 46 of the 49 animals the team sampled. H5N1 turned up in only a few.
“We are very concerned with the impacts of bird flu on Antarctic wildlife,” said Ralph Vanstreels, a wildlife veterinarian with the UC Davis One Health Institute’s Latin America Program and the study’s senior author. But “this case is an important reminder that other pathogens continue to circulate.”
A Remote Stronghold
The Danger Islands, a small archipelago off the northern tip of the Antarctic Peninsula, are home to more than 1.2 million breeding pairs of Adélie penguins, one of the largest concentrations of the species anywhere. They are so remote and so choked with sea ice that the size of the colonies went largely unknown until about a decade ago.
The HPAI Australis Expedition was organized to track the spread of bird flu into the region. Funded by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators and Ocean Expeditions, with additional support from the European Union, the team combined lab testing, post-mortem examinations and genetic analysis to work out what had killed the birds.
An Old Disease, Hiding in Plain Sight
The genetic results held a second surprise. The strain of avian cholera behind the outbreak was closely related to one identified in Antarctic seabirds more than two decades ago. That suggests the bacterium has been circulating in the region for at least 20 years. The strain was also closely linked to bacteria found more than 8,000 kilometers away elsewhere in the Southern Ocean.
Avian cholera spreads quickly in crowded colonies, through contaminated water, soil and close contact, and it can kill birds within hours of infection. Seabirds that nest shoulder to shoulder by the hundreds of thousands are especially vulnerable.
“The findings suggest avian cholera may be a more widespread and underestimated cause of seabird mortality in Antarctica,” said Matteo Iervolino of Erasmus University in the Netherlands, the study’s lead author.
Why the Diagnosis Matters
Getting the cause right matters for more than the record books. Since H5N1 arrived in South America and then the Antarctic, researchers and wildlife managers have braced for mass die-offs and have poured resources into tracking the virus. If every large mortality event is assumed to be bird flu, the authors argue, other threats can go undetected and unmanaged.
It also matters for the people who visit. Antarctic tourism has grown sharply, and tour operators follow strict biosecurity rules to avoid carrying pathogens between colonies. Knowing that a bacterial disease is already established in the region shapes how those rules are written and enforced.
Adélie penguins already face pressure from a warming climate, which is reshaping the sea ice they depend on for feeding and the krill populations at the base of their food web. A disease that can sweep through a colony in a season adds another layer of risk, and one that scientists say deserves far more attention than it has received.
Sources: UC Davis, Proceedings of the Royal Society B.
